United States: Amy Silverman Secures Court Victory for Investigative Journalism Access
Ruling has broader implications for journalistic access to public records and the oversight of government agencies
Location: United States, Phoenix
Date: June 3, 2024
Women Press Freedom commends the Arizona Supreme Court's ruling in support of journalist Amy Silverman, who faced obstruction from the Department of Economic Security in accessing records related to vulnerable adults. While this ruling represents a significant step forward, Silverman's persistent pursuit of access to these records is ongoing. The court has allowed the Department to present arguments to the trial judge regarding the alignment of Silverman's work with the "bona fide research" exception, leading to further legal proceedings. Women Press Freedom urges the Department of Economic Security to step back from the case and enable Silverman to continue her reporting without additional obstacles.
WPF denounces the attack on journalist Chinmayee Sahoo and her Argus News colleagues by former minister Das Raghunandan in Bhubaneswar.
WPF denounces Russia’s decision to revoke the accreditation of Carola Schneider, a seasoned Moscow correspondent for Austria’s ORF.
WPF stands in solidarity with Benazir Shah, a prominent Pakistani journalist, who recently endured a coordinated campaign of online harassment and had her Twitter account hacked following her comments on a blasphemy case.
The Arizona Supreme Court has ruled unanimously in favor of journalist Amy Silverman, affirming her right to access records from the Adult Protective Services (APS) division of the Department of Economic Security (DES).
Silverman, currently a staffer at KJZZ, had pursued the records four years ago as part of her investigation into the Department of Economic Security's (DES) effectiveness in protecting vulnerable adults. Her request specifically targeted materials related to closed cases, with the understanding that DES would redact sensitive information such as names and addresses.
However, DES denied her request, citing confidentiality provisions designed to protect the privacy of individuals involved. Silverman countered by highlighting the "bona fide research" exception, which she argued should also apply to journalistic endeavors. The agency contested this interpretation, arguing that the exception was intended solely for academic researchers or research that would directly benefit the agency.
Despite this latest ruling, Silverman's quest for these records continues as the DES retains the right to challenge the applicability of this exception to her work.
Gregg Leslie, representing Silverman as the director of the First Amendment Clinic at the Arizona State University College of Law, highlighted the pivotal role that the Department's actions will play in the resolution of this case. The Supreme Court's delineation of the factors governing access serves as a framework for evaluating future decisions on the matter.
Tasya Petersen, the press secretary for the Department of Economic Security, affirmed that the agency is reviewing the ruling and intends to establish a factual record for future review by a trial judge.
Women Press Freedom urges the DES to respect the Supreme Court's decision and withdraw from further legal obstruction. Allowing Silverman to continue her research without additional hindrance is essential for ensuring transparency and accountability in the protection of vulnerable adults. But this ruling, while specifically addressing APS records, has broader implications for journalistic access to public records and the oversight of government agencies. Women Press Freedom calls on the Department of Economic Security to honor the spirit of the Supreme Court's ruling and permit Silverman to pursue her investigation without further impediments. Transparency and accountability are cornerstones of a democratic society, and journalists like Silverman play a crucial role in upholding these principles.
The International Women’s Media Foundation (IWMF) has decided to revoke the 2024 Courage in Journalism Award from freelance Palestinian journalist Maha Hussaini.
WPF expresses our deepest solidarity with Linda Tirado, a courageous photojournalist who was gravely injured by Minneapolis police while covering the George Floyd protests in 2020.
WPF expresses solidarity with journalists, including Laura Guido from The Idaho Press, who were arbitrarily denied access to cover the biennial Idaho Republican State Convention.
Olivia Reingold, a reporter for The Free Press, faced intimidation tactics from protesters who labeled her a "Zionist."
WPF commends court's ruling in support of Amy Silverman, who faced obstruction from the Department of Economic Security in accessing records related to vulnerable adults.
WPF announces that we have joined the Freedom of the Press Foundation (FPF) and 122 other organizations and individuals in a unified call to Senator Dick Durbin to advance the PRESS Act.
WPF applauds the recent settlement in a groundbreaking lawsuit brought by investigative journalist Brittany Hailer against Allegheny County Jail.
WPF stands in unwavering solidarity with the Media Matters for America (MMFA) team affected by recent layoffs, as the media watchdog attributes legal pressures, including a lawsuit from Elon Musk, as a contributing factor in the decision to let go of a dozen of its employees.
WPF is gravely concerned by the escalating arrests, assaults, detentions, and obstructions faced by predominantly student journalists covering protests on campuses across the United States.
WPF stands in full solidarity with the journalists and contributors of Knock LA in their pursuit of editorial independence and fair treatment.
WPF stands in support of Sandra Fish, an experienced political journalist with the Colorado Sun, who was ejected from the state Republican party assembly by the party chairman for ‘being biased.’
Although state agencies are not admitting wrongdoing, WPF celebrates the recent $1.2 million settlement reached by journalists Carolyn Cole and Molly Hennessy-Fiske with the Minnesota State Patrol as a pivotal moment in the ongoing struggle for press freedom and journalist safety in the United States.
WPF vehemently condemns the libel lawsuit filed against Laura Belin, editor of Bleeding Heartland, and contributor Marie Gleason.
WPF condemns the Russian government's recent imposition of personal sanctions on more than 200 American citizens, including government employees, academics, and notably, journalists — citing what it perceives as unjustified and hostile actions by the United States government.
WPF expresses deep concern over the alarming and aggressive rhetoric employed by Member of Parliament Zahid Oruc towards prominent US-based journalist Sevinj Osmanqizi and her fellow exiled colleagues from Azerbaijan.
WPF stands in full support of Amanda Moore, whose journalistic rights were blatantly infringed upon during the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC).
WPF voices deep concern about the ongoing significant layoffs in the 2024 journalism job crisis, including recent significant staff cuts at NowThis and The Intercept.
Comment section of the podcaster's video about her infant son’s open heart surgery flooded with demands she speak out about the Israel-Hamas war.
New Hampshire Public Radio journalist Lauren Chooljian was ordered to hand over unpublished notes and transcripts in a libel case brought against the journalist by Eric Spoffard.
Women Press Freedom welcomes the settlement between the Minneapolis City Council and seven journalists attacked by police during protests following George Floyd’s killing in 2020.
WPF welcomes the resolution of the legal battle faced by journalist Lisa Kwon, who courageously stood her ground against a defamation lawsuit filed by a landlord following her investigative report on illegally operated Airbnbs in Los Angeles.
CFWIJ and WPF expresses its unequivocal support for E. Jean Carroll and extends its wholehearted appreciation for the court's decision to grant her $83.3 million in the defamation lawsuit against former President Donald Trump.
Recent announcements by The Arena Group and the Los Angeles Times of significant layoffs carry deep implications for the fabric of our media, particularly for the representation and voices of journalists of color.
CFWIJ and WPF stands in solidarity with Priscilla Villarreal, a citizen journalist who has been denied damages in her lawsuit following her unlawful arrest in 2017.
CFWIJ and WPF stands firmly in support of Laura Belin's legal battle against House Chief Clerk Meghan Nelson for consistently denying her press accreditation to report on the Iowa House of Representatives.
CFWIJ and WPF welcomes the recent passage of the Protect Reporters from Exploitative State Spying (PRESS) Act, H.R. 4250, by the U.S. House of Representatives.
Media conglomerate Condé Nast has announced the merger of Pitchfork, a prominent music publication, with GQ, a men's interest magazine, resulting in widespread job cuts.
CFWIJ and WPF is deeply concerned about the abrupt dismissal of Houston Landing’s editor-in-chief Mizanur Rahman and Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter Alex Stuckey.
Women Press Freedom is an initiative by The Coalition For Women In Journalism
The Coalition For Women In Journalism is a global organization of support for women journalists. The CFWIJ pioneered mentorship for mid-career women journalists across several countries around the world and is the first organization to focus on the status of free press for women journalists. We thoroughly document cases of any form of abuse against women in any part of the globe. Our system of individuals and organizations brings together the experience and mentorship necessary to help female career journalists navigate the industry. Our goal is to help develop a strong mechanism where women journalists can work safely and thrive.
If you have been harassed or abused in any way, and please report the incident by using the following form.
WPF strongly condemns the forceful expulsion of Caroline Haskins from the MindTheTech conference in New York City on March 4, 2024.