Mexico: SLAPP Filed Against Claudia Amelia Solera Seeks $18 Million in Damages
Women Press Freedom urges the court to dismiss unjust lawsuit against Solera
Location: Mexico, Mexico City
Date: May 6, 2024
A multimillion-dollar lawsuit against Claudia Amelia Solera raises serious concerns over the use of judicial mechanisms to inhibit and intimidate journalistic work. The journalist is being sued for an astronomical amount concerning an investigation published in 2010. Judicial harassment and Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPPs) are increasingly common in Mexico, stifling critical journalism. The courts must distinguish between factual reporting and opinion, protect expressions on matters of public interest, and carefully scrutinize damage claims to uphold journalistic integrity. Women Press Freedom vehemently denounces this lawsuit targeting Claudia Amelia Solera. Given the article's publication over 13 years ago, the statute of limitations should nullify the possibility of legal action. We call upon the Twenty-Third Civil Court of Written Procedure of the Superior Court of Justice of Mexico City to dismiss this baseless lawsuit.
WPF strongly condemns the ongoing legal proceedings against Gözde Bedeloğlu, a journalist for BirGün, who is currently facing charges of "insulting a public official" in Istanbul, Turkiye, filed by a Nationalist Movement Party politician.
During the ongoing Israel/Palestine conflict, the fundamental principles of press freedom have come under dire threat.
WPF welcomes the judgment of the Fair Work Commission that found that broadcaster Antoinette Lattouf was fired by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) following a social media post by Lattouf sharing a Human Rights Watch claim about Israel's actions in Gaza.
On May 6, 2024, two women visited the home of journalist Claudia Amelia Solera to serve her with a lawsuit. One of the women claimed to be a court clerk from the Twenty-Third Civil Court of Written Procedure of the Superior Court of Justice of Mexico City but lacked formal identification. The other woman, also unidentified, purportedly represented the plaintiff, Mario Alberto Quiroz, a lawyer from Mexico City.
The lawsuit against Solera is based on a 2010 article she wrote, exposing predatory practices by a law firm targeting retirees. Mario Alberto Quiroz, implicated in the investigation, is demanding 300 million pesos (nearly $18 million) for moral damages.
The demand for 300 million pesos is significantly higher than what is legally allowed for moral damages in Mexico City. The Civil Liability Law for the Protection of the Right to Privacy, Honor, and Image in Mexico City caps moral damages at 350 times the Unit of Account of Mexico City. This unit is a standard measure used for financial calculations and legal limits. The amount demanded in the lawsuit against Solera is far beyond this legal limit, suggesting the demand is excessive and potentially an intimidation tactic rather than a legitimate legal claim.
Judicial harassment, including Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPPs), has surged in Mexico. Earlier this month, Women Press Freedom documented a similar lawsuit initiated against investigative journalist Fabiola Cortés Miranda by Four Cardinals Development México SA de CV. The company is demanding $3.6 million for "material damages" and an additional 5 million pesos for "serious moral damages" from Miranda. The lawsuit aims to intimidate Miranda, who reported on a legal dispute involving indigenous Mayans in Quintana Roo over land rights.
These legal maneuvers aim to intimidate, inhibit, or silence critical opinions or information related to matters of public interest. SLAPPs not only impact the targeted journalists economically and psychologically but also serve as a broader deterrent, warning the press against publishing certain topics or engaging with certain people under the threat of legal action.
Women Press Freedom denounces this legal action against Claudia Amelia Solera as an attempt to intimidate and silence investigative journalism. Considering the time elapsed since the publication of her report, in 2010, over 13 years ago, the statute of limitations should also be considered, extinguishing the possibility of legal action due to the passage of time. We urge the courts to administer justice and swiftly dismiss this nuisance lawsuit, allowing the journalist to work freely without the threat of legal intimidation.
WPF expresses solidarity with Anabel Hernández and Reyna Ramírez, who were singled out by President Andrés Manuel López Obrador during a press conference.
Women Press Freedom expresses profound alarm at judicial decisions granting freedom to a former governor and a former police chief accused of torturing investigative journalist Lydia Cacho.
WPF vehemently condemns the intimidation and obstruction faced by journalists Yessica Ayala and Joselyn Meneses at the hands of fifteen residents in San Jerónimo Coyula, Atlixco, Puebla.
WPF firmly supports Anabel Hernández, who says President Andrés Manuel López Obrador's administration is imposing censorship on her latest book, 'The Secret History: AMLO and the Sinaloa Cartel’.
WPF stands resolutely behind Fabiola Cortés Miranda, an investigative journalist affiliated with the independent media outlet Periodismo en Colectivo and human rights organization Somos tus Ojos.
WPF stands in full support of Stephanie Palacios, who received threats on social media after asking President Andrés Manuel López Obrador during the morning press conference about alleged sanctions against journalists.
A multimillion-dollar lawsuit against Claudia Amelia Solera raises serious concerns over the use of judicial mechanisms to inhibit and intimidate journalistic work.
WPF is appalled by the recent events in Torreón, Mexico, where journalist Camelia Muñoz faced egregious attacks while performing her duties.
WPF unequivocally stands in solidarity with esteemed journalist Laura Brugés following her sudden termination from Radio Formula.
WPF strongly condemns the arrest of five women journalists in Zacatecas and the physical assault of at least three others in various regions of Mexico while covering International Women's Day marches.
WPF strongly condemns Mexico's President, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, for justifying his decision to disclose the phone number of Natalie Kittroef, the New York Times Bureau Chief for Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean, by asserting that the legal prohibition on officials sharing personal information does not apply to him.
CFWIJ and WPF is deeply concerned about the recent government data breach in Mexico, which has exposed the personal information of hundreds of journalists.
CFWIJ and WPF condemns the recent judicial verdict exonerating the lone defendant in the Pegasus Spyware case involving the esteemed journalist Carmen Aristegui.
WPF strongly condemns the egregious and unacceptable acts of sexual and psychological violence perpetrated against the journalists, and sisters, Natalie and Michelle Hoyos López by police officers in Puebla, Mexico.
CFWIJ and WPF stands in unwavering solidarity with Cinthya Alvarado Enríquez, an independent journalist bravely undertaking a hunger strike in response to the delayed reparation of damages she suffered.
The Coalition For Women In Journalism and Women Press Freedom condemns the online smear campaign targeting journalist Reyna Haydee Ramírez.
Armed men in the violence-plagued state of Guerrero kidnapped Journalist Silvia Nayssa Arce, her husband Alberto Sánchez, and journalist Marco Antonio Toledo with his wife and son on November 19 and 22 respectively.
Journalist Sandy Guadalupe González Rodríguez, a reporter for Canal 5TV, received threatening messages from Mayela Sánchez Román, assistant to deputy Luis Humberto Aldana Navarro, in Chetumal, Quintana Roo.
Rosario Martínez De la Vega, a correspondent for Los Angeles Press in Guanajuato, was intimidated by an alleged police agent.
Following Claudia Isela Hernández Pérez’ live broadcast reporting on the murder of businesswoman Angela Louise Birkenbach, the journalist was sent several threats by a fake online profile.
Estrella Pedroza, a Mexican journalist and regular contributor to the progressive daily La Jornada, was assaulted by approximately ten police officers.
Former Tamaulipas Governor, Francisco Cabeza de Vaca, issued legal threats against journalist Martha Olivia López following her publication on the discovery of human remains in clandestine graves on his property.
Governor and Secretary of Government in Oaxaca attacks journalist María Nivón Molano at a press conference, accusing her of lying after reporting on the escalating violence in the state.
Journalist María Luisa Estrada Hernández escapes an assassination attempt in Guadalajara after authorities refuse to protect her.
Investigative journalist María Teresa Montaño Delgado was kidnapped and threatened due to her exposé of corruption allegations involving the misappropriation of millions of taxpayer funds by the State of Mexico (Edomex).
Yessenia Mollinedo Falconi and Sheila Johana García Olivera, the director and a reporter of online news portal El Veraz, respectively, were shot dead outside a convenience store in broad daylight.
Television host Michelle Perez Tadeo was found dead in Mexico City on February 22, 2002.
Journalist Lourdes Maldonado López was shot by unidentified assailants while she was in her car.
Women Press Freedom is an initiative by The Coalition For Women In Journalism
The Coalition For Women In Journalism is a global organization of support for women journalists. The CFWIJ pioneered mentorship for mid-career women journalists across several countries around the world and is the first organization to focus on the status of free press for women journalists. We thoroughly document cases of any form of abuse against women in any part of the globe. Our system of individuals and organizations brings together the experience and mentorship necessary to help female career journalists navigate the industry. Our goal is to help develop a strong mechanism where women journalists can work safely and thrive.
If you have been harassed or abused in any way, and please report the incident by using the following form.