France: Far-Right Trolls Target Nassira El Moaddem
WJournalist’s social media flooded with hate after she comments on racism
Location: France
Date: May 1, 2024
Women Press Freedom strongly denounces the racist harassment targeting Nassira El Moaddem. Her online comment, taken out of context and amplified by the far-right, was used to justify further harassment based on her minority background. Despite being French, she was told to leave the country by a far-right politician, a blatant discriminatory remark. Journalists from France of minority backgrounds have repeatedly faced threats and online harassment for commenting in public on race or expressing themselves on social media. This torrent of abuse, directed at El Moaddem was amplified by right-wing media outlets. We demand justice for El Moaddem, any users issuing threats of violence against her online must be held to account.
WPF condemns the violent manner in which CNN News18 reporter Yesha Kotak was attacked by a police constable in Mumbai.
WPF is deeply concerned about the passage of the controversial "foreign agents" law by the Georgian parliament.
WPF is deeply concerned about the well-being of Chinese citizen journalist Zhang Zhan over her untraceable whereabouts on the day of her expected release from Shanghai Women's Prison after four years.
Nassira El Moaddem, a journalist with Arrêt sur Images, became the target of online harassment and a flood of hateful messages after she posted a tweet denouncing racism in France.
The harassment began on May 1, 2024, after she reacted to news from the soccer sports federation about banning certain attire on soccer pitches in the name of secularism. Expressing her dismay in a tweet, she referred to France as a "country of degenerate racists."
The situation escalated when TV host Jean-Marc Morandini discussed El Moaddem's tweet on his show on CNews. On the program, a member of the far-right National Rally party, Julien Odoul, called for El Moaddem’s dismissal from Radio France, despite her not being associated with the station since 2022. Personal attacks on her nationality and background ensued, with Odoul callously suggesting she leave France, despite her French citizenship.
Following this, El Moaddem became the target of a torrent of hateful comments on social media, including threats and racist language. These attacks were further fueled by outlets associated with Vincent Bolloré, a prominent figure in French business and media known for his conservative views and aggressive tactics.
The harassment extended beyond personal abuse to target her past employers. Outlets linked to Bolloré's group reached out to France Inter, where El Moaddem had previously worked, seeking their reaction to her tweet. France Inter's initial response, which seemed to downplay her association with the station, drew criticism for echoing the sentiments of the cyberbullies.
This provoked outrage from El Moaddem's supporters, including politicians like Cyrielle Chatelin and Danièle Obono. Eventually, France Inter revised its statement, removing controversial phrases, but El Moaddem expressed disappointment at the station's lack of support during the onslaught of hostile messages she faced online.
On May 3, 2024, France Inter issued another statement, explicitly condemning the violent attacks El Moaddem faced on social media while reaffirming that her views did not represent the station's stance.
The Society of Journalists of Arrêt sur Images and Médiapart stood in solidarity with El Moaddem, condemning the coordinated attack by the far-right against her.
Sadly, racist attacks on women journalists in France are not uncommon. Renowned journalist Rokhaya Diallo has also endured years of relentless harassment, both online and through legal channels. United Nations Special Rapporteur Mary Lawlor has expressed deep concern over Diallo's sustained harassment.
The swift and severe backlash Nassira El Moaddem experienced, fueled by powerful figures and amplified by right-wing media outlets, underscores the urgent need to combat online harassment. No journalist should endure such vicious attacks simply for expressing their views. As we stand in solidarity with El Moaddem and others facing similar persecution, we must demand concrete action from the French government and online platforms to protect journalists from racist attacks. Social media users must not be free to threaten, discriminate, and harass without consequences.
WPF strongly denounces the racist harassment targeting Nassira El Moaddem. Her online comment, taken out of context and amplified by the far-right, was used to justify further harassment based on her minority background.
WPF vehemently condemns the gendarmerie’s physical assault against France 3 Occitanie journalist Miryam Brisse and the obstruction of the crew, including Harmonie Pacione, from covering environmental protests against the construction of the A69 motorway.
WPF stands in solidarity with French freelance journalists Céline Martelet and Édith Bouvier, who are harassed online — including being sent death threats — after being handed ten and twelve months of suspended imprisonment by the Paris Court of First Instance in a terrorism-related case.
WPF vehemently denounces the onslaught of death threats and harassment directed at renowned cartoonist Corinne Rey — known as Coco — for her cartoon depicting a Palestinian family navigating survival in Gaza during the holy month of Ramadan.
CFWIJ and WPF is deeply disturbed by veteran French journalist Michel Drucker’s unacceptable remarks towards women sports journalists.
Spanish journalist and author Ruth Baza has accused French film star Gérard Depardieu of raping her nearly 30 years ago.
Following an intense confrontation on Franceinfo between journalist Salhia Brakhlia and politician Marion Maréchal, Brakhlia was attacked with racist insults from the far-right on social media.
CFWIJ is deeply concerned about the recent threats against Ruth Elkrief, a respected French Jewish columnist working with TV broadcaster LCI.
The Coalition For Women In Journalism strongly condemns the conduct of the Gendarmerie towards Adeline Percept and Thomas Chantepie of Swiss public broadcaster Radio-Télévision Suisse (RTS).
CFWIJ is deeply concerned for exiled ex-Russian state television journalist Marina Ovsyannikova after a suspected poisoning attempt.
Moscow court convicts former state TV editor Marina Ovsyannikova of spreading “false information” about the Russian military.
Following Ariane Lavrilleux’s groundbreaking investigation into the French government's involvement in "arbitrary executions" in Egypt, intelligence officers arrest the investigative journalist and search her home.
French journalists hit with crowbars while covering violent uprising after police kill teenager.
Compagnies Républicaines de Sécurité (CRS) officer attacks a woman journalist on her way home and strangles the reporter after seeing her press card.
Journalist Harmony Pondy-Nyaga was forcibly removed by police while filming an environmental protest in Paris.
Le Media TV’s Chloé Gence was manhandled, strangled, and forcibly arrested by police while covering pension reform protests.
Journalists Tiphaine Niederlaender and Christelle Rewiako assaulted by art thief Stéphane Breitwieser.
Maria Malagardis is on trial over alleged public insult against Aloys Ntiwiragabo, the former head of military intelligence in Rwanda.
Two video journalists, including a woman working for the Agence France-Presse (AFP) were attacked during an anti-vax protests in Paris.
Photographer Estelle Ruiz was physically assaulted by protesters during an anti-vax demonstration in Nantes in France.
Eight women journalists have lifted anonymity from the allegations of sexual misconduct against newsreader Patrick Poivre d'Arvor.
Journalists Lisa Noyal and Rémi-Kenzo Pagès were restricted from questioning Mayor of Aubervilliers, Karine Francelet regarding a demolition project in her region of jurisdiction. Francelet’s security team threatened legal action and destroyed the journalists’ property for merely attempting to do their job. This is not the first time such an incident has occurred. The journalists have also been previously discouraged from pursuing the story and the constant attempts to silence the noise around the issue now appears extremely concerning.
Andreina Mujica, a Franco-Venezuelan journalist was called by the French police against a complaint filed by the counsel of Venezuela on June 8. The complaint against Andreina was filed by Venezuelan counsel Glenna Cabello, who accused the journalist of posting threats to her life in a Facebook post on March 12, 2019. As per Andreina, the Facebook post in question was done by her to demand the release of a journalist Luis Carlos, captured by the state.
French journalist Isabelle Krismon has filed criminal defamation complaints against unknown people who attacked her on social media. The journalist was following the investigation on a political movement “La Printemps Republican”. Her investigative stories were published on 4, 8, and 25th February in an online magazine, Slate. CFWIJ is following the situation of the defamation charges filed by Isabelle Kersimon.
Journalist Maty Fall, who is originally from Senegal, was sent death threats online while she was covering the event in her home country. The sheer volume of violence threats and abuses that she received caught the attention of local journalist unions and other civil society groups who have extended her support and condemned the campaign against her. Maty has since filed a complaint with the police.
Nadiya Lazzouni received an anonymous letter at her private residence. The letter was replete with sexist and Islamophobic slurs and included death threats. Nadiya believes that she was targeted for her religious visibility and expressed great fear about the implications of the perpetrator's access to her residential address.
Investigative reporter Morgan Large’s car was sabotaged in a manner that could have seriously put her life at risk. This is not the first attack on the journalist either. Within the past year and a half, Morgan endured several such attacks at her workplace as well as her home. Over time, it appears that these malignant efforts to intimidate her into silence have increased in frequency.
Women Press Freedom is an initiative by The Coalition For Women In Journalism
The Coalition For Women In Journalism is a global organization of support for women journalists. The CFWIJ pioneered mentorship for mid-career women journalists across several countries around the world and is the first organization to focus on the status of free press for women journalists. We thoroughly document cases of any form of abuse against women in any part of the globe. Our system of individuals and organizations brings together the experience and mentorship necessary to help female career journalists navigate the industry. Our goal is to help develop a strong mechanism where women journalists can work safely and thrive.
If you have been harassed or abused in any way, and please report the incident by using the following form.